Some people suggested that Vogue Italia should’ve reconsidered casting Hadid for the cover shoot.

“Your worst cover in years. You had to make her look black and her expression is so bad. Just hire a model of colour to do the job,” one person wrote.

“There are so many talented and beautiful models out there who could actually make a better cover.”

However, some members of Hadid’s loyal fan base ignored the criticisms and happily lauded the cover:

“Beauty beyond the face and a personification of strength. Love you so much Gi. And the cover is amazing,” wrote one adoring commenter.

The controversial cover marks Hadid’s second for the title, given that the model was also accused of cultural appropriation when she fronted VogueItalia in 2015 sporting an afro-style blue wig.